How To Write A Recruitment SLA Hiring Managers Will Follow

You've spent countless hours organising recruitment processes, only to discover that Hiring Managers inconsistently apply them. This inconsistency creates bottlenecks, leads to misaligned expectations, and ultimately prolongs the hiring process.

So, how do you craft a Recruitment Service Level Agreement (SLA) that actually gets followed? This comprehensive guide will walk you through the essentials of creating an effective Recruitment SLA. You'll discover how to ensure hiring managers adhere to the agreed processes, making your recruitment workflow smoother and more efficient.

1. Understanding Recruitment SLAs

1.1 What is a Recruitment SLA?

A Recruitment Service Level Agreement (SLA) is essentially a contract between the recruitment function and hiring managers. It sets out the expectations, processes, and performance metrics that both parties agree upon to ensure a seamless and efficient recruitment process. Think of it as the roadmap for collaboration between HR and hiring teams. It typically includes deadlines, candidate quality expectations, and communication protocols.

Let's break it down:

• Time Frames: Clear deadlines for each stage of recruitment, like screening or interviews, should be specified.

• Candidate Quality: Define what constitutes a qualified candidate and any competency expectations.

• Communication: Determine who will communicate feedback and the reporting format.

By outlining these elements, you set a clear framework that minimises confusion and streamlines the recruitment process. A well-structured SLA becomes the backbone of an effective recruitment strategy.

1.2 Why are Recruitment SLAs Important?

Recruitment SLAs are not just bureaucratic exercises; they provide a crucial framework for ensuring accountability and managing expectations. Without a robust SLA, recruiters and hiring managers can find themselves misaligned, leading to prolonged hiring times and missed opportunities for hiring top talent.

Highlights of Recruitment SLAs include:

• Improved Accountability: Each participant knows their responsibilities and timelines.

• Enhanced Efficiency: Streamlines recruitment by eliminating back-and-forth delays.

• Increased Transparency: Everyone involved has visibility into each step, reducing misunderstandings.

By instituting a Recruitment SLA, you are not only setting expectations but actively improving the recruitment ecosystem within your organisation. This proactive step can be your key to gaining a competitive edge in attracting and securing top candidates.

According to SHRM, the average time to fill a position is already five to six weeks — and that figure is rising. Companies that implement well-defined recruitment SLAs are better positioned to buck this trend, keeping their hiring process structured, accountable, and competitive.

1.3 Key Elements of an Effective SLA

A successful Recruitment SLA comprises several critical elements, each contributing to a well-oiled hiring process. Understanding these components is essential for any SLA to be effective and practical.

Core Components:

• Timelines: Specify deadlines for each recruitment phase, such as time-to-respond and interview schedules.

• Roles & Responsibilities: Clearly define who is responsible for tasks like job postings, candidate screenings, or interview setups.

• Performance Metrics: Establish key performance indicators (KPIs) such as time-to-hire or candidate satisfaction rates.

Remember, an SLA should be a living document that evolves with organisational needs and market trends. Ensuring an adaptive approach allows you to keep your hiring process relevant and effective.

2. Creating a Recruitment SLA

2.1 Setting Realistic Timelines

Setting timelines that are realistic is crucial for a successful recruitment SLA. You don't want to end up with a plan that's impossible to follow. Consider the different stages of the hiring process when mapping out your timeline. For instance, the time taken for a structured interview can vary depending on the role's complexity and the number of candidates. Aim to set flexible deadlines that accommodate such variations while keeping the overall process efficient.

Ensure every timeline is rooted in historical data. Use previous recruitment cycles to understand the average duration of each stage. Also, consider the resources available, such as the number of recruiters or interviewers. If you're working with a limited team, a timeline that suits larger entities might not be feasible. Customise your timelines to fit your company's capacity, ensuring no stage of the recruitment process feels rushed or overlooked.

Pro-tip: Use project management tools to track progress. Keeping visual tabs on the timeline helps all stakeholders remain aware of upcoming deadlines and milestones.

2.2 Defining Roles and Responsibilities

A well-defined set of roles and responsibilities is the backbone of a robust recruitment SLA. Clarity in this area prevents the overlap of duties and ensures accountability throughout the hiring process. Clearly outline the responsibilities of each party involved, including HR professionals, hiring managers, and external recruiters if any. Specify who is responsible for screening applications, conducting interviews, and making final decisions.

To promote seamless collaboration, create a responsibility matrix. This tool helps identify the particular tasks assigned to each stakeholder, showing who is accountable, responsible, consulted, and informed for every part of the process. It's useful for onboarding new team members and serves as a quick reference to understand their specific duties in the context of recruitment.

Pro-tip: Regularly review roles and responsibilities. As your organisation evolves, so too will your recruitment needs. Adjust the responsibility matrix accordingly to avoid widespread confusion among team members.

2.3 Establishing Performance Metrics

Establishing clear performance metrics is fundamental for evaluating the effectiveness of your recruitment SLA. Common metrics include time-to-fill, cost-per-hire, and the quality of hire. While these are standard, it's necessary to adapt them to your organisation’s unique requirements. Explore additional metrics that align with your business goals, such as candidate satisfaction scores.

When creating these benchmarks, ensure they're both measurable and meaningful. For example, setting a goal for candidate satisfaction rates can offer insight into your candidates’ experiences with your recruitment process, equipping you with data for improvements. Also, determine how often these metrics will be reviewed - monthly or quarterly reviews often provide timely insights without overwhelming the team with data.

Pro-tip: Link your metrics to strategic objectives. When performance indicators align with the broader business goals, you foster a recruitment function that truly supports your company's vision.

3. Encouraging Compliance and Adoption

3.1 Communicating the SLA to Hiring Managers

Effective communication is the foundation for ensuring that your Service Level Agreement (SLA) is understood and followed by hiring managers. Start by presenting the SLA in a straightforward manner during a dedicated meeting or webinar. Use simple language and provide real-world examples of how the SLA has improved recruitment outcomes in similar companies. Highlight key elements through case studies or role-playing scenarios that demonstrate expected performance and timelines within the recruitment process.

To foster understanding and acceptance, tailor your explanation to the specific needs and challenges faced by hiring managers in your organisation. This might involve acknowledging sector-specific nuances or past challenges within your company. Use visuals or infographics to break down complex points, making the SLA more approachable. By engaging hiring managers from the start, you increase the likelihood of their commitment to the SLA.

Pro-tip: Host an interactive session where hiring managers can ask questions and provide real-time feedback on the SLA. It encourages active participation and clarifies expectations.

3.2 Monitoring and Reporting on SLA Performance

Consistent monitoring and transparent reporting are essential to reinforce the importance of your SLA. Initiate a simple process to track the SLA’s metrics regularly, using platforms like Tableau or Power BI to create dashboards displaying pertinent data. These tools can quickly visualise compliance rates and identify areas for improvement.

In your reports, focus on key performance indicators (KPIs) such as time-to-hire, quality of candidates, and manager satisfaction scores. Present this data in monthly meetings, showcasing successes and challenges.

According to LinkedIn's Future of Recruiting report, quality of hire is best measured through a combination of job performance ratings, new hire retention, and hiring manager satisfaction — all metrics that regular SLA reporting directly supports. Use these insights not only to adjust strategies but also to recognise and reward teams achieving outstanding results in adherence to the SLA.

Pro-tip: Incorporate a “success stories” section in your reports to spotlight teams whose adherence to the SLA has positively impacted recruitment outcomes. It promotes a culture of recognising achievement while encouraging others to improve.

3.3 Adjusting the SLA Based on Feedback and Performance

Flexibility in your SLA ensures that it remains relevant and effective as needs change. Gather feedback from hiring managers through regular surveys or focus groups and make adjustments when necessary. Address concerns promptly, demonstrating a willingness to adapt the SLA to new challenges or improvements in the hiring process.

Be proactive in using past performance data to support your decisions. For example, if data shows a consistent delay in hiring for technical roles, revise the timelines laid out in the SLA or allocate additional resources to those stages of recruitment. This iterative process not only keeps your SLA current but also reinforces your commitment to meeting the evolving needs of all parties involved.

Pro-tip: Establish a quarterly review process where hiring managers and recruitment teams collaboratively discuss the SLA’s performance, fostering continuous improvement and buy-in from all stakeholders.

In conclusion, crafting a recruitment SLA that is both useful and followed by hiring managers involves clear communication, continuous monitoring, and a willingness to adjust based on performance and feedback. By prioritising these elements, you create a collaborative environment that aligns everyone’s efforts towards efficient hiring practices.

If your team is responsible for hiring 20+ roles this quarter, we’re offering a fully supported first-role run on the Evidenced platform.

Apply to run your first role here.